Stack of 5 chocolate chocolate chip cookies

Bringing Magic to Every Bite

ABOUT SUGAR WITCH MAGICAL TREATS

Sugar Witch Magical Treats offers an elevated take on homestyle desserts. Known for enchanting cookies, cakes, cupcakes, and other treats in popular and custom flavors, Sugar Witch tasty treats and vibrant vibe aims to win over those who "don't even like cookies or cake" and turn them into total dessert lovers. We are a cottage business serving Yellow Springs, OH and the surrounding areas including Cincinnati, Columbus, and Dayton. Reach out today to taste the magic!

About

Sweet potato cupcakes with pecan buttercream frosting and pecan garnish

This Is How We Do It

OUR PHILOSOPHY

At Sugar Witch Magical Treats, we believe in making every moment extraordinary. Our passion for creating delightful treats is infused into every recipe we craft. We take pride in using the finest ingredients and paying attention to every detail to ensure that each bite is a magical experience for our customers.

DISCOVER OUR TREATS

VIEW GALLERY

Multiple cookies individually wrapped and packaged in a large box

🍰 Indulge in the Magic 🍰 Indulge in the Magic 🍰 Indulge in the Magic 🍰 Indulge in the Magic 🍰 Indulge in the Magic

FOLLOW US #SUGARWITCHDYT

Instagram

Packing up all the cozy vibes! 🍪🧁🍂 From classic chocolate chip to fall-favorite pumpkin scones, this custom order is ready to make someone’s day a little sweeter. Who’s ready to add some magic to their next order? ✨ #SugarWitchDelivers#FreshlyBakedMagic#homebakery #yellowsprings

✨See it. Like it. Want it? We know you do! 🍪 With Sugar Witch Magical Treats, it’s always cookie time. Ready to add a little magic to your day? DM us and order now!✨#yellowsprings #homebakery #secondstreetmarket #glutenfree #fiveriversmetroparks #daytonbaker

We love that you love it! 💕 Didn’t get a taste? Don’t be jealous! Hit us up or check us out at the 2nd Street Public Market in downtown Dayton on 10/27 from 11 - 3. #yellowsprings #ysstreetfair #fiveriversmetroparks #secondstreetmarket

Yellow Springs Street Fair October 2024 was another sold out event! 🤯 New and returning customers alike came thru for their Sugar Witch fix. Miss your chance? Don’t worry because we’ll be at Dayton 2nd Street Market on 10/27. Plus you know it ALWAYS goes down in the DM’s so hit us up! #yellowsprings #ysstreetfair #secondstreetmarket

Did you know we make full size cupcakes too?! 🤣 Congratulations New Season Ministry on your church anniversary!!! 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾Thank you for allowing us to celebrate with you.

Wheeling Gaunt was an enslaved man who after purchasing freedom for himself, his wife, and another relative settled in Yellow Springs in the 1860s. He has been an inspiration to the village ever since. Thank you @the365projectys for allowing Sugar Witch to play a small role in honoring such an impactful figure!

Did you know Sugar Witch has THE BEST gluten free chocolate chip cookies? 🍪 Crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside and loaded with chocolate, these delicious cookies please everyone! Try one for yourself. DM or click the link in bio to place your order.
#homebakery #glutenfree

Thank you to our fellow vendor selling farm fresh produce at 2nd Street Market! ☺️ The Vegan Lemon Crinkle Cookie is top-tier. Try it for yourself and tell us what YOU think!

What an amazing experience to share Sugar Witch Magical Treats with everyone at 2nd Street Public Market in downtown Dayton. It seemed like the whole day sparkled…We are now a regular outside vendor so stay tuned for our dates and be sure to pull up! #fiveriversmetroparks

Feeling the good Summer energy! Sugar Witch has been staying busy…
1 & 2. A beautiful cake for a beautiful soul celebrating a milestone birthday. It was an honor to be a part of the festivities 🥳
3. A little cookie experiment. We’re still in the lab 🥼 but we’re on the right track.
4. Thank you to Fairway Golf Club for allowing us to provide the treats for your annual golf tournament.

How do you eat an elephant? 🐘 One bite at a time…This Sugar Witch order started with an empty muffin tin and ended with a variety of over 1000 mini cupcakes! 🧁 Congratulations @bobrossautogroup for 50 years and thank you for letting Sugar Witch Magical Treats be a part.

Just a few satisfied customers! ❤️ What do you think about YOUR Sugar Witch cookie? #foodreview #cookiereview #daytonbaker #yellowsprings #yspride #yellowspringsstreetfair

Before…and after! We had a blast at the Yellow Springs Street Fair and completely sold out. Not once but twice!!! Be sure to reach out to see what all the fuss is about 😉#yellowspringsstreetfair #yellowspringsohio #bakery #homebakery

Some lovely people enjoying their Magical Treats at the Yellow Springs Street Fair. Just look at the pure joy!#yellowspringsohio #homebakery #smallbakingbusiness

These Pineapple Upside Down Cupcakes came in clutch! After a failed attempt at a pineapple upside down cake, we regrouped and created these lovelies. Moist yellow sponge, pineapple cooked with butter and brown sugar, cherry buttercream, with a cherry on top! #pineappleupsidedowncake #pineappleupsidedowncupcakes #cupcakesofinstagram

I love Autumn! It’s my absolute favorite and the perfect time for baking experiments. I present to you, sweet potato cupcakes with toasted marshmallow filling, pecan buttercream, and a candied pecan garnish, a pumpkin cake with warm spices (and a bit of black pepper!) and a browned butter maple glaze, and last but not least pumpkin butter cookies made with local pumpkin butter. These were designed as part of a special Fall treat box, but of course are available at any time so if you’re interested, hit me up! Keep your eyes open for more seasonal treat boxes to come…#treatboxesofinstagram #treatbox #seasonalbaking #autumnvibes🍁 #autumnbaking

I consider it a privilege when asked to be a part of others’ most special days, especially birthdays! My intention when baking is to make something that brings a smile to someone’s face. For a chocolate-peanut butter lover (like myself ☺️), this totally fits the bill. Rich chocolate cake, creamy peanut butter filling and frosting, finished with chocolate ganache and chopped peanut butter cups. Whew…
Sound like you need one? You know where to find me!
#baking #bakery #homebaker #chocolatepeanutbutter #cake

Flashback to September 2023 when I was honored to bake for the World House Choir 10th Anniversary celebration. It has been one of the true joys of my life to be a member of this loving, vibrant, activist, hardworking, striving-to-make-the -world-a-better-place organization! Here we have a two-layer carrot cake with caramel filling and brown-butter cream cheese frosting, vanilla cupcakes with vanilla buttercream, and chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting. They were a hit!
#baking #bakery #homebaker #worldhousechoir #yellowsprings #yellowspringsohio

Sugar Cookies, Gluten-free Shortbread with Lemon Drizzle, and Chocolate Chip Cookies all packaged up and ready to go. Thank you @theproject365ys
For your giant box of cookies, just reach out!

So…decorating sugar cookies is not REALLY my thing. It’s healthy to admit weakness, right? Right?! All in all these were simple yet elegant and most importantly delicious. #sugarcookies #sugarcookiesofinstagram #homebakery

Crisp white shirt, little black dress…chocolate chip cookie?? May seem odd but cookies sure are a staple for me! Add this classic to your menu anytime by emailing sugarwitchdyt@gmail.com, sending a DM, or checking out the order form linked in bio. #chocolatechipcookies #homebakery #cookiesofinstagram

Stay tuned. Somethin’ sweet dropping soon…

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@sugarwitchdyt

Contact